Usury in Orthodoxy
Quote from Ryan Augustine on March 5, 2022, 18:59Does anyone know when the Eastern Orthodoxy churches started permitting usury (if they did)? I remember something about the Byzantine emperor being indebted to Venice which kicked off the sack of Constantinople during the 4th crusade.
Does anyone know when the Eastern Orthodoxy churches started permitting usury (if they did)? I remember something about the Byzantine emperor being indebted to Venice which kicked off the sack of Constantinople during the 4th crusade.
Quote from Timothy Fitzpatrick on March 7, 2022, 19:42Not sure, Ryan. But I would like to know as well.
Not sure, Ryan. But I would like to know as well.
Quote from Ryan Augustine on March 8, 2022, 15:03I tried some digging and found this article which I thought was pretty interesting. Apparently it pays to be a patriarch! Krill is reportedly worth $4 billion. https://amp.dw.com/en/russian-orthodox-church-tries-to-make-hay/a-18648735
I tried some digging and found this article which I thought was pretty interesting. Apparently it pays to be a patriarch! Krill is reportedly worth $4 billion. https://amp.dw.com/en/russian-orthodox-church-tries-to-make-hay/a-18648735
Quote from Timothy Fitzpatrick on March 11, 2022, 20:48Can you give a summary of what you discovered?
Can you give a summary of what you discovered?
Quote from Ryan Augustine on March 14, 2022, 21:12From krill and banking:
Basically the article says Kirill is worth about 4 billion. As of 2015 he is as trying to set up an orthodox bank, which would use the consumer banking accounts to bet on the stocks and other financial instruments. Basically what western banks do. (1)
Kirill does not seem to have a problem taking loans “Russia c.bank to lend $1.2 bln to save Orthodox Church bank” (2)
As for the history of usury in the EO. Looks like loans were always permitted in the Byzantium Empire.
Justinian was the first empire to codify loans and set interest rates, which lowered the rates from Roman times. However the rates would increase later in history. Interestingly the interest rate for churches was set at 3% (3)
Usury may have gotten it’s start in Eastern Orthodxy at the end of the 16th century when money lenders set up their operations right next to the Patriarchate! This was called the PHANAR (5)
It seems that the Greek Orthodox Church was involved in usury at least as far back as 1872 which in part caused the Bulgarian split (5)
The article goes into say that Greek EO gradually submitted to the power of the PHANAR
”Greek bishops under the Ecumenical Patriarchy bought their offices. The normal price for the Patriarchate was 15000 ducats while a regular yearly sun was required to keep their see.” (Ibid)
However the article states that this is because of Turkish rule. But the writer is EO so….
As a side note I am not sure this qualifies as usury, I am a bit agnostic on what the definition of usury is, but I think Pharisee Hoffman probably goes to far:
Matthew 25:27
“The scholastics of the 15th century took up this form[17] for full investigation. They approved it but as in the case of “commenda.” They introduced limitations to the freedom of the contract so as to secure a just relation of creditor and debtor. These limitations were the following: first, the creditor has no right to require his capital back; second, the debtor has the right of redemption if he wants it“ (4)
Although I do believe that making money off money does seem to violate the principle of our banishment from Eden which we are to work for a living.
That’s all for now but I’ll keep researching.
1: https://amp.dw.com/en/russian-orthodox-church-tries-to-make-hay/a-18648735
2: https://www.google.com/amp/s/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSL8N1HR3MI
3: https://btcm.co/roman-and-byzantine-interest-rates-the-byzantine-empire-395-1453-a-d/amp/
4: https://www.naturalmoney.org/doctrineusury.html
5: https://www.rusjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Exarchate.pdf
From krill and banking:
Basically the article says Kirill is worth about 4 billion. As of 2015 he is as trying to set up an orthodox bank, which would use the consumer banking accounts to bet on the stocks and other financial instruments. Basically what western banks do. (1)
Kirill does not seem to have a problem taking loans “Russia c.bank to lend $1.2 bln to save Orthodox Church bank” (2)
As for the history of usury in the EO. Looks like loans were always permitted in the Byzantium Empire.
Justinian was the first empire to codify loans and set interest rates, which lowered the rates from Roman times. However the rates would increase later in history. Interestingly the interest rate for churches was set at 3% (3)
Usury may have gotten it’s start in Eastern Orthodxy at the end of the 16th century when money lenders set up their operations right next to the Patriarchate! This was called the PHANAR (5)
It seems that the Greek Orthodox Church was involved in usury at least as far back as 1872 which in part caused the Bulgarian split (5)
The article goes into say that Greek EO gradually submitted to the power of the PHANAR
”Greek bishops under the Ecumenical Patriarchy bought their offices. The normal price for the Patriarchate was 15000 ducats while a regular yearly sun was required to keep their see.” (Ibid)
However the article states that this is because of Turkish rule. But the writer is EO so….
As a side note I am not sure this qualifies as usury, I am a bit agnostic on what the definition of usury is, but I think Pharisee Hoffman probably goes to far:
Matthew 25:27
“The scholastics of the 15th century took up this form[17] for full investigation. They approved it but as in the case of “commenda.” They introduced limitations to the freedom of the contract so as to secure a just relation of creditor and debtor. These limitations were the following: first, the creditor has no right to require his capital back; second, the debtor has the right of redemption if he wants it“ (4)
Although I do believe that making money off money does seem to violate the principle of our banishment from Eden which we are to work for a living.
That’s all for now but I’ll keep researching.
1: https://amp.dw.com/en/russian-orthodox-church-tries-to-make-hay/a-18648735
2: https://www.google.com/amp/s/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSL8N1HR3MI
3: https://btcm.co/roman-and-byzantine-interest-rates-the-byzantine-empire-395-1453-a-d/amp/
4: https://www.naturalmoney.org/doctrineusury.html
5: https://www.rusjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Exarchate.pdf
Quote from Ryan Augustine on March 18, 2022, 21:41I have a sneaky suspicion that the followers of Levi Sabbatai wound up in the PHANAR, or Fener, Greek financial quarter. But I’ll need to do more digging….
I have a sneaky suspicion that the followers of Levi Sabbatai wound up in the PHANAR, or Fener, Greek financial quarter. But I’ll need to do more digging….
Quote from Ryan Augustine on January 24, 2023, 23:03Domanovskyi A. Alms, Loans, and Usury in the Byzantine Worldview: An Essay in Comparison893Andrii DomanovskyiV. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, Kharkiv, Ukraine;andriy.domanovsky@karazin.uaAlms, Loans, and Usury in the Byzantine Worldview:An Essay in ComparisonTe moral evaluation of credit and financial operations can serve as one of the clearestindicators of a society’s “economic worldview”. Byzantium, where trade went hand in hand withan extensive development of credit and usury, was not an exception. It has become commonplaceto assert that usury was perceived negatively in Byzantine society, that charging interest wascondemned energetically, that this condemnation derived its power from the spontaneous popularattitude towards such practices, and that it actively employed Christian rhetoric. o support suchclaims, scholars usually cite hagiographic sources, where trade and finances are oen mentioned.For instance, Byzantinologists oen bring upTe Miracles of the Great-Martyr Artemius(570–660). Tis text relates the story of the son of a money changer and usurer, whom his parents triedto get to join his father’s occupation but who, being a religious boy, was so ashamed of his father’s“miserable and shameful livelihood”, gained by charging the debtors enormous interest, that hebecame a cleric.Gregory of Nyssa also wrote about the rapacity of usurers, who desired people to suffer“deprivations and misfortunes” and come to them for financial aid. In his words, the money-lender“counts his income daily, and is never satisfied with it; deplores the gold that lies in his home, forit remains without any employment and profit.” According to John Chrysostom, manytrapezites “attach interest to interest and pursue by way of iniquity any lucre”.“Te mental trap” of the Byzantine society was created on the one hand by the developingtrade, which demanded credit institutions, and on the other hand by the condemnation of usury. Itrequired an adequate solution at the level of ideology and worldview. Probably one way to resolvethe contradiction can be detected by comparing the «theoretical» level of the attitudes towardsusury, most fully elaborated for the early Byzantine times in theA Word against Usurersby Gregoryof Nyssa (335–396), with the «practical» level of credit operations.InA Word against Usurersit is said that the borrowing of money is “the same as begging foralms, only having an air of propriety,” and therefore one should give to the needy not only withoutcharging them interest, but also without demanding the money back, i.e. not requiring the returnof the principal. Te preacher considered an interest-free loan to be “the second degree of charity,”following the first degree,“gratuitous giving”. He claimed that “both are worthy of punishment whenone person refuses to favor and the other person borrows more than a tax”. It seems interesting to impose this framework from Gregory of Nissa’s sermon on the data fromTe Life of St.Spyridon ofrimythous(died about 348 AD) by Teodorus, Bishop of Paphos (c. 625).Spyridon gave alms toa naukleros who solicited it under the pretense of a loan (with an airof propriety), that is, he implemented the “first degree of charity.” Te saint’s indifference as to the894repayment of the debt is notable – he does not inquire or confirm whether or not the merchantreturned the money, or if the merchant did it in full, because Spyridon has given alms, not a loan.And when the merchant, having deceived Spyridon and not returned what he had taken, asks formoney again, the saint does not refuse him and allows the merchant to take what he asks for fromthe chest. Without a doubt, the saint once again perceives this act as a giving of alms, and is willingto do it if his means prove sufficient.Te merchant interprets the situation differently. Initially he is consistent in returning whathe has received from the saint, and later, when his fraud is exposed, he begs for forgiveness andevidently believes it mandatory to repay the debt. He seems to perceive the saint’s actions as “thesecond degree of charity.” He is probably certain that his perception of the saint’s giving him moneyas an interest-free loan coincides with Spyridon’s view of the events.TusTe Life of StSpyridon of rimythousdemonstrates how the model of a byzantine believer’srelation to alms, loans, and usury, worked out by Gregory of Nyssa on a general theoretical level,could and was supposed to function in practice, allowing even a saint to act as a money-lender.As we can see, even a saint could, according to the hagiographic literature, act as a money-lender, if he did not charge any interest. We also find this motive in theLifeof St. John the Merciful,Patriarch of Alexandria (610–619), written by Leontios of Neapolis (620s–640s). John repeatedlylent to merchants in Alexandria both money (including considerable sums of five to ten liters ofgold) and goods and did not complain when a borrower was not able to repay the debt even aer asuccessful return to Alexandria.Even more interesting is another aspect notably emphasized inTe Life of St. Spyridon, namelythe idea of the just repayment of the money borrowed. Obviously, theLifestresses, it is proper notonly to lend money without interest, but also to repay debts in a timely fashion and in full. Probablythis is how the principle of business relations laid down in the New estament (“do to others whatyou wouldwant them do to you,” Matthew 7:12) was supposed to be applied in practice.However, demands postulated by preachers could not be consistently realized in practice, andsimple considerations of piety, not connected to receiving profit, could not force potential lendersto part with their assets: “We will not lend, or lend but on the condition that the borrower paysuch and such amount of interest,” relates Gregory of Nyssa the typical attitude of early-Byzantinelenders. Note that, according to Nicholas Kabasilas, late-Byzantine usurers acted similarly: “Tey(the usurers –A. D.), because it is prohibited to charge interest, decide not to lend, themselvesabolish creditors in cities and censure the law for it”. And even more clearly: “No one will lendmoney if there is no hope of receiving interest”.Te inviability of the preached treatment of usury was unequivocally demonstrated by Basil I’s(867–886) attempt to prohibit charging interest on loans (Prochiron. XVI. 14). Only to minors andorphans were excluded from the prohibition. Based on the Christian attitude toward the chargingof interest, the emperor’s measures were hailed by the broad populace. But they did not last long,and already Leo VI (886-912) relinquished them in his novellas. While considering Basil’s lawwonderful, he had to admit that without charging interest the very existence of credit is threatened(Les Novelles de Leon VI le Sage LXXXIII). “Tis instruction (of Basil I’s about the prohibition ofinterest –A. D.), as a result of the poverty of the people, led not to the better, as the lawgiver hadthought, but to the worse. Previously, hoping for interest, many would lend money willingly; but895when the law appeared according to which it was prohibited to derive profit from lending, somebecame inhuman, cruel, and unfeeling towards those in need of a loan... As a result... the law thatwas in itself benevolent has not brought benefit but has caused harm... Te nature of man has notreached the heights at which this law obtains, and therefore we abolish this wonderful law.” Tusthe church’s appeals about the prohibition of interest, “reduction of debts and complete forgivenessof debt obligations (chreon apocopai, othlematon synchoreseis),” asTe Life of George of Amastrisputs it, remained futile.In other words, practice showed that the high ideal reflected in the law of Basil I wasincompatible with the realities of everyday life, had a negative impact on business dealings, andimpeded the progress of trade. Tese circumstances forced Leo VI to return to the old legislationof Justinian, which acknowledged the practice of charging interest but regulated its upper limitsdepending on the social status of the creditor (Basil. XXIII. 3. 73, 74, 76; compare: Cod. Just. IV. 26;IV. 32; Nov. Just. 32, 1 etc.). Just like in the sixth century, professional usurers were allowed to charge8 percent annual interest, members of the nobility – 4 percent, and everyone else – 6 percent. Inspecial cases with the high risk of the loss of capital (primarily loans for maritime trade), charging12 percent was allowed (Basil. XXIII. 3. 72, 74, 76; compare: Cod. Just. IV. 26; IV. 32; Nov. Just. 32,1). Te highest allowed interest could not be exceeded even by the mutual agreement of the parties.If, in violation of the law, excess interest was actually charged, the money paid unlawfully were tocount toward the repayment of the principal.Clearly, such interest rates were quite sufficient for the normal conduct of credit operationsand for decent levels of profit.Eastern Islamic cities of the eleventh century arrived naturally atcommensurate levels of interest rates – they rarely went over 6–10 percent annual.Tus Leo VI considered usury a “necessary evil”, avoiding which would be desirable but,unfortunately, impossible. Te realities of life inexorably compelled the abandonment of abstractideals. We can observe a similar pattern in the medieval Islamic East, where on the one hand usurywas condemned, but on the other hand the impossibility of conducting trade without credit wasacknowledged.Tis iswhy the general attitude towards usury in Byzantium was, it seems, ambivalent ratherthan purely negative. Tis ambivalence was reflected, among other things, in hagiographic works,where usurers were sometimes shown in even the mostpositive light. So it was in the prologue aboutTeodore the merchant and the Jewish usurer Abram. In this text, Abram agreed to give Teodore aloan three times without demanding the repayment of the previously lent sums and accepting onlyan image of Jesus Christ as a surety of sorts. In the end, when the debtor aer a successful trading voyage was able to repay the loan handsomely, giving back four thousand liters instead of just onethousand that he had borrowed, the Jew was so struck by the power of the Christian God that hechanged his faith and put all his money into building a chapel where he then served as aminister.Clearly, even the negatively perceived occupation of usurer was still not, using the expression of R.Lopez, “an object of indiscriminate hatred.”We may suppose that “indiscriminate hatred” and total condemnation was avoided by thoseusurers who did not dare to break the law and charge higher interest than prescribed. Te activitiesof such moneylenders were allowed by the state itself, when the latter determined the interestrates the charging of which did not incur a breach of the Christian canon. o some extent, the law896that regulated the charging of interest performed a kind of compensatory function – it allowedmoneylenders the easier to agree to engage in an activity generally frowned upon in the societypervaded by Christian traditions. As Nicholas Kabasilas noted, moneylenders did not shun theirincome precisely because their pursuits were not condemned by the law (and were even encouraged,or at least acknowledged as necessary, we can add).Certainly this is only a conjecture, but we should note that such an attitude existed in theOttoman Empire. Tere, credit operations at fixed interest (20 percent) were not considered usuryand not perceived as a breach of the Qur’anic prohibitions. Only those credit transactions thatentailed the charging of interest in excess of 20percent were considered riba (usury as such). It isquite possible that something like this could be the case in the early medieval Byzantium as well,where secular and religious customs and practices were closely intertwined. Tis was the way inwhich religion, in the words of Fernand Braudel, while constantly saying no to “the innovationsof market, money, speculation, and usury,” in the end said yes and accepted the “aggiornamento –adaptation to modernity”.It is interesting also to juxtapose the idea of limited interest with the idea of a “just price”(iustum pretium, to dicaion timema) and regulated profit margins for the members of some ofConstantinople’s corporations. Te “just price” idea also found its way into the hagiographicliterature, and the hagiographer of Anthony the Great (fourth century) put the following words inthe saint’s mouth: “In this present life the price of a thing bought is equal to what it is worth, and theseller receives no more than that. But the promise of eternal life is acquired for too little a price: it isgiven to us for a life momentary”. In Byzantium, as in Western Europe, the activities of a merchantwere considered justified if the principle of just compensation was not violated. It is quite possiblethat the same applied to usury.Clearly, the described attitude towards usury was not only the most expedient, but also theonly possible one in a Christian society that experienced not only religious purism and fanaticism,but also the sense of gain and profit. It infiltrated so deeply into the worldview of the Byzantines thateven alms for the poor were equated with a loan extended to none other than God himself: “For itis said, ‘He who gives to a poor man, lends to God. And Holy God will recompense... and bestowthe kingdom of heaven’”https://www.academia.edu/28706759/Domanovskyi_A._Alms_Loans_and_Usury_in_the_Byzantine_Worldview_An_Essay_in_Comparison





Share this:
- Share on X (Opens in new window) X
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
- Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
- Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky
- Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
- Print (Opens in new window) Print
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Share on Mastodon (Opens in new window) Mastodon
- Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
