Chinese willing to pay dearly for Israeli engineers
Quote from Timothy Fitzpatrick on August 17, 2022, 23:14
While the Chinese giant Alibaba closed its Israeli center, Huawei especially needs Western knowledge and experience, and they are also willing to pay dearly for it • In the meantime, despite being blacklisted in the US, Huawei's operations in Israel are larger than ever and they employ about 500 people in research groups in Haifa and Hod The Sharon • Third article in the series
How do you disconnect from Chinese high-tech?
In May 2019, the US Department of Commerce put the Chinese communications and technology giant Huawei on a "blacklist". This means that American companies or those that use American technology require a license to sell to those located there. Along with Huawei, another 68 of its subsidiaries from around the world entered the list at that time. 46 additional subsidiaries were added to the list in August 2019.
But one name is surprisingly absent from both lists - Toga Networks, Huawei's research branch in Israel. Toga's offices in Hod Hasharon and Haifa were also surprised that they were not included in the lists, and to this day it is not entirely clear how the Israeli branch managed to avoid this. One of the explanations that came up among the employees is that Toga's name, which does not contain the word Huawei, confused the American authorities, but apparently this is not the case. In any case, in August 2020 the grace period ended, and Toga was put on the list in the third round along with other Huawei entities, from Chile in South America to Singapore in Southeast Asia.
According to former employees, the period between Huawei's entry into the list and Toga's entry was used by the Israeli affiliate to increase its equipment for testing and development before sanctions were imposed on it as well. In some cases, according to former employees, the suppliers, who did not want to risk getting into trouble with the American government, asked for a statement from managers at Toga that the equipment would only be used by Israeli workers at the branch in Israel. Sources close to the development center claim that there was no such special purchase and that equipment was purchased only according to the needs of the project.
After entering the blacklist, Toga was prevented from using popular software such as the "MATLAB" programming tool. Instead, Toga employees use open source substitutes, non-American software or tools developed at Huawei. Following the sanctions, there were also employees who left the center out of fear that working at Huawei could harm their future careers, and especially future employment with American companies.
Despite all this, two years after Toga entered the list, the company's centers in Israel are larger than ever and employ about 500 employees in 12-14 research groups, responsible for projects in various fields. As of today, while other development centers are reducing recruitments, Toga is recruiting for 55 open positions. While another Chinese giant, Alibaba, closed its development center in Israel last month, it seems that the Israeli centers are especially important to Huawei, possibly because of the American sanctions.
Red sheet for Americans
For the US, Huawei has been considered a red sheet in recent years. An approach that began in the days of Trump and continues under President Biden, who did not cancel or ease the sanctions. The Americans accuse Huawei of a series of heavy accusations, the most serious of which is that it planted back doors in its communication equipment that allow spying, Although to date no evidence of this has been presented.
This month, CNN published that the FBI is convinced that Huawei equipment placed at sites near missile facilities and military bases in the United States is capable of intercepting and intercepting military communications, including communications of the Strategic Command that oversees the nuclear facilities. The Americans blame Huawei and its affiliate in the United States, Futureway ( Futurewei) also in the systematic theft of intellectual property and trade secrets, an issue that forms the basis of a lawsuit that the US Department of Justice filed against the companies in 2020. According to the claims in the lawsuit, Huawei previously operated a bonus program to reward employees who obtained confidential information and tried to obtain information by recruiting employees from American companies In response, Huawei argued that the lawsuit recycles old civil disputes that it had with American companies such as Cisco and T-Mobile and that had already been resolved a long time ago.
The Americans believe that Huawei is an extension of the Chinese government. This claim is based, among other things, on the background of the company's founder, Ren Zhengfei, who founded it in 1987, after being discharged from the Chinese army - a fact that helped him win the first contracts at the beginning. Huawei's unique and strange ownership structure, in which 99% of the shares are held by a workers' organization, also contributes to suspicion. Of course, Huawei rejects this and claims that they are a completely private company that is owned by its employees, who are represented by the workers' organization.
It is difficult to recruit Westerners
Guilty or not guilty, the sanctions managed to significantly damage Huawei's operations. In 2021, the company lost nearly $37 billion, 29% of its revenue, in what was the first annual decline in revenue in at least two decades. Smartphone sales, which is Huawei's core business, have been severely damaged.
The US sanctions blocked Huawei from using Google apps, making the company's smartphones worthless in the West. In addition, the US prevented Huawei from producing its most advanced chips at TSMC factories in Taiwan, making it difficult for the Chinese giant to compete with the new devices of Apple and other companies even in the domestic Chinese market.
While in 2020, just before the full entry into force of the sanctions, Huawei managed to momentarily become the largest smartphone manufacturer in the world, last year the company was completely pushed out of the top. The sale of communication equipment - Huawei's original activity - was also affected after the US put pressure on its allies around the world not to integrate the Chinese company into the state-of-the-art cellular networks in their country.
But Huawei is far from giving up and is trying to reinvent itself by entering new areas - ones where the Americans will be less likely to interfere. The fields include cloud software and services, medicine and even automobiles. This month, the Chinese electric vehicle brand Aito opened for pre-orders ten thousand vehicles of a new model, whose operating system was developed by Huawei. The vehicles were hijacked within two hours.
The Municipality of Bishkek is launching a tender for the construction of a recreation and leisure complex in the city
To complete such a major change in direction, from smartphones and routers to cloud software, Huawei spent $22 billion on research and development last year, almost a quarter of its revenue, and the same amount that Apple spent on development. Except that beyond money, Huawei needs talents, talented and knowledgeable technologists, not only in China but in the whole world. "We have enough money and enough space for global talent," said founder and CEO Ren in an internal speech revealed on the Nikkei Asia website last June. In the same speech, Ren called on executives to identify promising candidates to build Huawei's "fighting power" as quickly as possible.
The sanctions blocked Huawei from accessing some of its international employees. Huawei used to donate or fund research programs at prestigious international universities to attract young talent, but after being blacklisted, prestigious institutions such as Berkeley and Oxford canceled the collaborations. In addition, the sanctions de facto blocked all research activity at Huawei's American branch, Futureway, which was located in Silicon Valley. At its peak, the branch employed 850 people, but has since cut back dramatically. Futureway itself, since it is an American company, is not on the list, but since its parent company is, it is not allowed to transfer knowledge and technology to it.
To gain access to experience gained in the West, and to engineers with Western training, Huawei has to rely on its research centers in Europe, which as of the end of 2021 employed about 2,400 researchers in 24 centers, including those in Israel. "Israeli workers, much more than Europeans, are a source of experience that comes from leading American companies," claimed an official in the field.
"Feels like pumping knowledge"
Toga Networks was founded in 2009 by Itzik Malovni, former engineer at Indigo and development manager at the start-ups Connect-One and Tera-Chip. In the beginning, Toga was a subcontractor for research and development work for the Huawei center in Germany and the first project Malovni led was the development of a chip for the company's routers. At the same time as Melovani, Amnon Sandrowitz, an outgoing ECI engineer, also separately started working on software developments for Huawei Germany and later the two teams merged under the name Toga.
Toga's first office was in Herzliya, but after the company grew, it was moved to Hod Hasharon. "Bavai did not want the offices to be adjacent to those of other communication equipment companies, if only so as not to look small next to the competitors, that's why Hod Hasharon was chosen in the end," said a source familiar with the details. The Haifa branch was also added several years ago.
Over the years, Toga has kept a very low profile and has played down its connection to the Chinese parent company. "Wawi wanted to keep a low profile because they have a lot of sales to Arab countries and also to the center in Israel. This suited them because they didn't need advertising and public relations at the same time," said the same source. In 2016, Huawei officially acquired Toga from Lebanon and since then the relationship has become visible.
The working method at Toga, which is defined as a research center, is different from that which exists in the other foreign centers in Israel. While in the other centers a complete product is developed from start to finish, or at least some component of a complete product, the Israeli team at Toga mainly builds the architecture of products and solutions, usually reaching the proof of feasibility (POC) or initial demonstration at most. Then, the accumulated knowledge is transferred entirely to China, where the architecture is translated into a product or service. The center boasts that they register 90-100 new patents every year.
At Toga believe that this approach properly utilizes the valuable Israeli engineer at the most important stage and does not "waste" him on a process that can be done cheaply elsewhere. The accepted method at Huawei is in many cases to let several teams around the world work on the same problem, with the one who progresses faster being the winner of the project. A former Toga employee claims this is a problematic approach. "Unlike Western development centers in Israel, Huawei's center in Israel has no warranty for any product," he claimed. "In Toga they tell the engineers in Israel to take a problem, solve it and pass it on to the team in China, when you're not always sure exactly which product it will end up with. It sometimes feels like the goal is to draw on the knowledge of the employees."
Those close to the center rejected this claim and said that every project in Israel is linked to a team in China and defined where it goes. "No one will let us build a generic project," they say. According to them, when it comes to the transfer of intellectual property, the center takes extra care and employees who are accepted to Toga, sign that they do not bring inside information from the previous workplace with them: "Even at the job interview stage, candidates are told that they do not have to answer questions that could reveal commercial secrets of other workplaces." The insiders point out that it was Toga that issued letters to other companies to make sure that employees who left it did not bring intellectual property with them.
In addition to the Israeli employees at the center, Huawei is bringing to Israel a team of experts from China. The experts, engineers by profession, are affiliated with the various research groups. Their official role is to coordinate between the Israeli team and the Chinese team that accompanies them in the project, while bridging the language and mentality gaps, but there are also those at the center who see the Chinese team as a supervisory factor, passing on information about the progress in Israel to the team in China. "Information always flows in only one direction: from Israel to China and not the other way around and all decisions are made there," claimed a former employee.
The export license was revoked
Already at an early stage Malovni and Sandrowitz, who retired from the center a few years ago and is now the director of a consulting company, established contacts with officials in Huawei's management and succeeded in getting them excited about Israeli innovation. The center boasts a series of significant developments for Huawei, such as a cloud database that retrieves information many times faster than Oracle's. Another development that started in Israel is the set of tools that allows developers to build and test applications that will run on Huawei's cloud.
As of today, Huawei owns 18% of the public cloud market in China and is trying to compete with the market leader Alibaba, which has a 37% share. Part of this competition is over the software and services provided by the different clouds. "You have to understand that historically Huawei is a company that is used to selling boxes and physical equipment. It did not know at all how to provide software services in the cloud (SAAS) and the ones who helped it with this were the centers around the world," says an insider to the company.
The profile of the Israeli workers at Toga is considered high and many of them have degrees in science or engineering from the leading universities. Toga is known as someone who pays very high wages and distributes signing bonuses that are quite generous in relation to the market, which in the past upset quite a few Israeli companies that lost employees to them.
A review of the LinkedIn accounts of Toga employees and job ads published by the company reveal the variety of areas the center deals with, which include cloud storage, automotive, blockchain, computer vision, databases, information security, and video. Some of the fields that appear can be considered sensitive, such as high-performance computing or by its sexier name - supercomputing (HPC).
Supercomputing has been a source of particularly intense strategic competition in recent years between the US and China. However, those close to Toga emphasize that at the center they firmly refuse to accept projects that can be considered dual-use technology, that is, developments that can be converted to military use, and also with regard to supercomputing only operate within the permitted range. In addition, Toga is supervised by the Ministry of Economy and must obtain an export license for technologies that can be converted to some military use. In at least one case, Globes learned, Toga's export license for a certain technology was revoked. In response, Huawei decided to transfer the development of the technology to Britain, where the export laws easier.
https://www.globes.co.il/news/article.aspx?did=1001419820

While the Chinese giant Alibaba closed its Israeli center, Huawei especially needs Western knowledge and experience, and they are also willing to pay dearly for it • In the meantime, despite being blacklisted in the US, Huawei's operations in Israel are larger than ever and they employ about 500 people in research groups in Haifa and Hod The Sharon • Third article in the series
How do you disconnect from Chinese high-tech?
In May 2019, the US Department of Commerce put the Chinese communications and technology giant Huawei on a "blacklist". This means that American companies or those that use American technology require a license to sell to those located there. Along with Huawei, another 68 of its subsidiaries from around the world entered the list at that time. 46 additional subsidiaries were added to the list in August 2019.
But one name is surprisingly absent from both lists - Toga Networks, Huawei's research branch in Israel. Toga's offices in Hod Hasharon and Haifa were also surprised that they were not included in the lists, and to this day it is not entirely clear how the Israeli branch managed to avoid this. One of the explanations that came up among the employees is that Toga's name, which does not contain the word Huawei, confused the American authorities, but apparently this is not the case. In any case, in August 2020 the grace period ended, and Toga was put on the list in the third round along with other Huawei entities, from Chile in South America to Singapore in Southeast Asia.
According to former employees, the period between Huawei's entry into the list and Toga's entry was used by the Israeli affiliate to increase its equipment for testing and development before sanctions were imposed on it as well. In some cases, according to former employees, the suppliers, who did not want to risk getting into trouble with the American government, asked for a statement from managers at Toga that the equipment would only be used by Israeli workers at the branch in Israel. Sources close to the development center claim that there was no such special purchase and that equipment was purchased only according to the needs of the project.
After entering the blacklist, Toga was prevented from using popular software such as the "MATLAB" programming tool. Instead, Toga employees use open source substitutes, non-American software or tools developed at Huawei. Following the sanctions, there were also employees who left the center out of fear that working at Huawei could harm their future careers, and especially future employment with American companies.
Despite all this, two years after Toga entered the list, the company's centers in Israel are larger than ever and employ about 500 employees in 12-14 research groups, responsible for projects in various fields. As of today, while other development centers are reducing recruitments, Toga is recruiting for 55 open positions. While another Chinese giant, Alibaba, closed its development center in Israel last month, it seems that the Israeli centers are especially important to Huawei, possibly because of the American sanctions.
Red sheet for Americans
For the US, Huawei has been considered a red sheet in recent years. An approach that began in the days of Trump and continues under President Biden, who did not cancel or ease the sanctions. The Americans accuse Huawei of a series of heavy accusations, the most serious of which is that it planted back doors in its communication equipment that allow spying, Although to date no evidence of this has been presented.
This month, CNN published that the FBI is convinced that Huawei equipment placed at sites near missile facilities and military bases in the United States is capable of intercepting and intercepting military communications, including communications of the Strategic Command that oversees the nuclear facilities. The Americans blame Huawei and its affiliate in the United States, Futureway ( Futurewei) also in the systematic theft of intellectual property and trade secrets, an issue that forms the basis of a lawsuit that the US Department of Justice filed against the companies in 2020. According to the claims in the lawsuit, Huawei previously operated a bonus program to reward employees who obtained confidential information and tried to obtain information by recruiting employees from American companies In response, Huawei argued that the lawsuit recycles old civil disputes that it had with American companies such as Cisco and T-Mobile and that had already been resolved a long time ago.
The Americans believe that Huawei is an extension of the Chinese government. This claim is based, among other things, on the background of the company's founder, Ren Zhengfei, who founded it in 1987, after being discharged from the Chinese army - a fact that helped him win the first contracts at the beginning. Huawei's unique and strange ownership structure, in which 99% of the shares are held by a workers' organization, also contributes to suspicion. Of course, Huawei rejects this and claims that they are a completely private company that is owned by its employees, who are represented by the workers' organization.
It is difficult to recruit Westerners
Guilty or not guilty, the sanctions managed to significantly damage Huawei's operations. In 2021, the company lost nearly $37 billion, 29% of its revenue, in what was the first annual decline in revenue in at least two decades. Smartphone sales, which is Huawei's core business, have been severely damaged.
The US sanctions blocked Huawei from using Google apps, making the company's smartphones worthless in the West. In addition, the US prevented Huawei from producing its most advanced chips at TSMC factories in Taiwan, making it difficult for the Chinese giant to compete with the new devices of Apple and other companies even in the domestic Chinese market.
While in 2020, just before the full entry into force of the sanctions, Huawei managed to momentarily become the largest smartphone manufacturer in the world, last year the company was completely pushed out of the top. The sale of communication equipment - Huawei's original activity - was also affected after the US put pressure on its allies around the world not to integrate the Chinese company into the state-of-the-art cellular networks in their country.
But Huawei is far from giving up and is trying to reinvent itself by entering new areas - ones where the Americans will be less likely to interfere. The fields include cloud software and services, medicine and even automobiles. This month, the Chinese electric vehicle brand Aito opened for pre-orders ten thousand vehicles of a new model, whose operating system was developed by Huawei. The vehicles were hijacked within two hours.
The Municipality of Bishkek is launching a tender for the construction of a recreation and leisure complex in the city
To complete such a major change in direction, from smartphones and routers to cloud software, Huawei spent $22 billion on research and development last year, almost a quarter of its revenue, and the same amount that Apple spent on development. Except that beyond money, Huawei needs talents, talented and knowledgeable technologists, not only in China but in the whole world. "We have enough money and enough space for global talent," said founder and CEO Ren in an internal speech revealed on the Nikkei Asia website last June. In the same speech, Ren called on executives to identify promising candidates to build Huawei's "fighting power" as quickly as possible.

The sanctions blocked Huawei from accessing some of its international employees. Huawei used to donate or fund research programs at prestigious international universities to attract young talent, but after being blacklisted, prestigious institutions such as Berkeley and Oxford canceled the collaborations. In addition, the sanctions de facto blocked all research activity at Huawei's American branch, Futureway, which was located in Silicon Valley. At its peak, the branch employed 850 people, but has since cut back dramatically. Futureway itself, since it is an American company, is not on the list, but since its parent company is, it is not allowed to transfer knowledge and technology to it.
To gain access to experience gained in the West, and to engineers with Western training, Huawei has to rely on its research centers in Europe, which as of the end of 2021 employed about 2,400 researchers in 24 centers, including those in Israel. "Israeli workers, much more than Europeans, are a source of experience that comes from leading American companies," claimed an official in the field.
"Feels like pumping knowledge"
Toga Networks was founded in 2009 by Itzik Malovni, former engineer at Indigo and development manager at the start-ups Connect-One and Tera-Chip. In the beginning, Toga was a subcontractor for research and development work for the Huawei center in Germany and the first project Malovni led was the development of a chip for the company's routers. At the same time as Melovani, Amnon Sandrowitz, an outgoing ECI engineer, also separately started working on software developments for Huawei Germany and later the two teams merged under the name Toga.
Toga's first office was in Herzliya, but after the company grew, it was moved to Hod Hasharon. "Bavai did not want the offices to be adjacent to those of other communication equipment companies, if only so as not to look small next to the competitors, that's why Hod Hasharon was chosen in the end," said a source familiar with the details. The Haifa branch was also added several years ago.
Over the years, Toga has kept a very low profile and has played down its connection to the Chinese parent company. "Wawi wanted to keep a low profile because they have a lot of sales to Arab countries and also to the center in Israel. This suited them because they didn't need advertising and public relations at the same time," said the same source. In 2016, Huawei officially acquired Toga from Lebanon and since then the relationship has become visible.
The working method at Toga, which is defined as a research center, is different from that which exists in the other foreign centers in Israel. While in the other centers a complete product is developed from start to finish, or at least some component of a complete product, the Israeli team at Toga mainly builds the architecture of products and solutions, usually reaching the proof of feasibility (POC) or initial demonstration at most. Then, the accumulated knowledge is transferred entirely to China, where the architecture is translated into a product or service. The center boasts that they register 90-100 new patents every year.
At Toga believe that this approach properly utilizes the valuable Israeli engineer at the most important stage and does not "waste" him on a process that can be done cheaply elsewhere. The accepted method at Huawei is in many cases to let several teams around the world work on the same problem, with the one who progresses faster being the winner of the project. A former Toga employee claims this is a problematic approach. "Unlike Western development centers in Israel, Huawei's center in Israel has no warranty for any product," he claimed. "In Toga they tell the engineers in Israel to take a problem, solve it and pass it on to the team in China, when you're not always sure exactly which product it will end up with. It sometimes feels like the goal is to draw on the knowledge of the employees."
Those close to the center rejected this claim and said that every project in Israel is linked to a team in China and defined where it goes. "No one will let us build a generic project," they say. According to them, when it comes to the transfer of intellectual property, the center takes extra care and employees who are accepted to Toga, sign that they do not bring inside information from the previous workplace with them: "Even at the job interview stage, candidates are told that they do not have to answer questions that could reveal commercial secrets of other workplaces." The insiders point out that it was Toga that issued letters to other companies to make sure that employees who left it did not bring intellectual property with them.
In addition to the Israeli employees at the center, Huawei is bringing to Israel a team of experts from China. The experts, engineers by profession, are affiliated with the various research groups. Their official role is to coordinate between the Israeli team and the Chinese team that accompanies them in the project, while bridging the language and mentality gaps, but there are also those at the center who see the Chinese team as a supervisory factor, passing on information about the progress in Israel to the team in China. "Information always flows in only one direction: from Israel to China and not the other way around and all decisions are made there," claimed a former employee.
The export license was revoked
Already at an early stage Malovni and Sandrowitz, who retired from the center a few years ago and is now the director of a consulting company, established contacts with officials in Huawei's management and succeeded in getting them excited about Israeli innovation. The center boasts a series of significant developments for Huawei, such as a cloud database that retrieves information many times faster than Oracle's. Another development that started in Israel is the set of tools that allows developers to build and test applications that will run on Huawei's cloud.
As of today, Huawei owns 18% of the public cloud market in China and is trying to compete with the market leader Alibaba, which has a 37% share. Part of this competition is over the software and services provided by the different clouds. "You have to understand that historically Huawei is a company that is used to selling boxes and physical equipment. It did not know at all how to provide software services in the cloud (SAAS) and the ones who helped it with this were the centers around the world," says an insider to the company.
The profile of the Israeli workers at Toga is considered high and many of them have degrees in science or engineering from the leading universities. Toga is known as someone who pays very high wages and distributes signing bonuses that are quite generous in relation to the market, which in the past upset quite a few Israeli companies that lost employees to them.
A review of the LinkedIn accounts of Toga employees and job ads published by the company reveal the variety of areas the center deals with, which include cloud storage, automotive, blockchain, computer vision, databases, information security, and video. Some of the fields that appear can be considered sensitive, such as high-performance computing or by its sexier name - supercomputing (HPC).
Supercomputing has been a source of particularly intense strategic competition in recent years between the US and China. However, those close to Toga emphasize that at the center they firmly refuse to accept projects that can be considered dual-use technology, that is, developments that can be converted to military use, and also with regard to supercomputing only operate within the permitted range. In addition, Toga is supervised by the Ministry of Economy and must obtain an export license for technologies that can be converted to some military use. In at least one case, Globes learned, Toga's export license for a certain technology was revoked. In response, Huawei decided to transfer the development of the technology to Britain, where the export laws easier.
Share this:
- Share on X (Opens in new window) X
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
- Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
- Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky
- Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
- Print (Opens in new window) Print
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Share on Mastodon (Opens in new window) Mastodon
- Share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
